About The Song
“Papa What If” is a delightful and tender rendition by Rory Feek and his young daughter, Indiana (Indy) Feek, showcasing the unique bond between a father and his child. This duet, adapted from Shel Silverstein’s original song “Daddy What If” (famously recorded by Bobby Bare and his son), captures the innocence of a child’s curiosity and the reassuring wisdom of a loving parent. Rory and Indy’s version replaces “Daddy” with “Papa,” adding a personal touch that reflects Indy’s affectionate name for her father.
The song’s charm lies in its simplicity and authenticity. Each verse poses whimsical “what if” scenarios, highlighting a child’s wonder about the world and a parent’s steady, comforting responses. Indy’s bright and enthusiastic delivery is a perfect counterpoint to Rory’s calm and tender reassurance, creating a dynamic that feels genuine and heartfelt. The lyrics convey a sense of security and joy, encapsulating the unique connection between a father and daughter in a way that resonates across generations.
Musically, “Papa What If” is grounded in a warm, acoustic arrangement that complements the song’s conversational tone. The gentle strumming of the guitar and understated production allow Rory and Indy’s voices to shine, emphasizing the intimate and personal nature of the song. Rory’s deep baritone harmonizes beautifully with Indy’s youthful voice, creating a blend that feels both nostalgic and timeless.
What makes this rendition so special is its backstory. After the passing of Indy’s mother, Joey Feek, in 2016, Rory embraced his role as a single father with devotion and love. “Papa What If” not only reflects their growing bond but also symbolizes the strength and resilience of their relationship. Rory’s decision to share this moment with Indy in a recorded performance and music video is a testament to the healing and joyful power of music within a family.
For fans of heartfelt music that celebrates the simple joys of life, “Papa What If” is a must-listen. Rory and Indy’s duet reminds us of the beauty in shared moments, the innocence of a child’s imagination, and the profound love between a parent and child. It’s a song that will leave a lasting impression, evoking smiles and warm memories for listeners of all ages.